ice cream maker guru

Whynter ICM 200LS vs Breville Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker Comparison

Are you shopping for ice cream makers and don’t know what to choose between Whynter ICM 200LS vs Breville Smart Scoop? Well, we can assure you that both of them are great options. However, every shopper has their preferences when it comes to the features, design, or price of their machine.

Whynter ICM 200LS vs Breville Smart Scoop

We’re going to help make your decision easier by comparing the two machines and their features. Let’s see what each has to offer in terms of capacity, appearance, weight, performance, and other features.

How Does the Whynter ICM 200LS Compare to the Breville Smart Scoop?

Product
Whynter ICM 200LS
Breville Smart Scoop
Whynter ICM-200LS Automatic Ice Cream Maker 2 Quart Capacity Stainless Steel, Built-in Compressor,...
Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker, Brushed Stainless Steel
Overall Score
4/5
5/5
Type
Compressor
Compressor
Capacity
2.1 quart
1.5 quart
Weight
24.25lbs
30lbs
Churn Time
25 minutes
28 minutes
Warranty
1 Year
1 Year
Bottom Line
Whynter is perfect for those who want an affordable yet high-quality ice cream maker
Breville is a high-quality ice cream maker that is easy to use and comes with a sleek design
Product
Whynter ICM 200LS
Whynter ICM-200LS Automatic Ice Cream Maker 2 Quart Capacity Stainless Steel, Built-in Compressor,...
Overall Score
4/5
Type
Compressor
Capacity
2.1 quart
Weight
24.25lbs
Churn Time
25 minutes
Warranty
1 Year
Bottom Line
Whynter is perfect for those who want an affordable yet high-quality ice cream maker
More Info
Product
Breville Smart Scoop
Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker, Brushed Stainless Steel
Overall Score
5/5
Type
Compressor
Capacity
1.5 quart
Weight
30lbs
Churn Time
28 minutes
Warranty
1 Year
Bottom Line
Breville is a high-quality ice cream maker that is easy to use and comes with a sleek design
More Info

Whynter ICM 200LS vs Breville Smart Scoop: Features

Capacity

The first thing that differentiates these two ice cream makers is the capacity. The ice cream maker machine from Whynter has a total capacity of 2.1 quarts, making more than ten servings at once. On the other hand, Breville Smart Scoop can store 1.5 quarts, which means that you’re able to create about five servings with it.

A bigger capacity of the ice cream maker also means a bigger footprint.

Breville Smart Scoop may take a smaller area than Whynter ICM 200LS, but that doesn’t mean that its capacity is inferior. The difference between the two machines can be compared to 2- or 4-quart ice cream makers, namely in terms of the time it takes for their preparation and the number of servings they produce. They’re two different machines, and that’s how they work as well.

Cost-Effectiveness

When shopping for the best ice cream maker machine, one of the things that matter is cost-effectiveness. You need something to produce great quality ice cream without breaking the bank.

The Whynter ICM 200LS is a great machine because it has several features, such as a timer and automatic shut-off, that make it easier to use. It usually retails at around $200.

On the other hand, the Breville Smart Scoop retails at $400, which is quite costly. But of course, the machine still comes with incredible features and performance that make it worth the price.

Appearance

When you’re the kind of person who cares about the looks of your ideal machine, you’ll be pleased to learn that both Whynter and Breville look pretty appealing to the eye. The Whynter ICM 200LS is a bit bulkier and has a more traditional look. It has a beautiful stainless steel finish that makes it look more expensive than it is.

The Breville Smart Scoop is, on the other hand, sleeker and has a nice brushed stainless steel finish that makes it look elegant as well. The ice cream maker looks very modern, so you’ll be proud to keep it in your kitchen.

Struggling to decide which Whynter Ice Cream Maker is right for you? Check out our Whynter Ice Cream Maker Comparison and Guide!

Weight

The weight of the machines also varies. The Whynter ICM 200LS weighs about 25 pounds, while the Breville Smart Scoop weighs 30 pounds. While the weight difference may not be a big deal for some people, you might want to consider this if you’re going to carry your ice cream maker with you for events.

However, don’t be discouraged by the fact that the Breville ice cream maker may be a bit heavier because it comes with a number of features that make it easier to use.

Settings

You’ll be pleased to learn that both machines are easy to operate and come with great controls. The Whynter ICM 200LS comes with an on/off switch, which is intuitive since it’s enough for you to know what the machine does.

On the other hand, the Breville Smart Scoop comes with a timer and auto shut-off feature. This means that you can set the timer to make your ice cream at a specific time, and the machine will turn off automatically when it’s done. This is a great feature because it prevents your ice cream from over-freezing or becoming too soft.

The Noise Levels

The noise level is another feature to consider, especially if you’re going to use your machine often or if you have young kids at home.

Both the Whynter ICM 200LS and Breville Smart Scoop produce a low noise level, so they’re both great options for ice cream makers. Whynter is considered the quietest as it only produces up to 72 decibels. On the other hand, the Breville ice cream maker produces about 73 decibels. The difference is not huge making them both wonderful machines at home.

Ice Cream Quality and Consistency

One of the most important things to consider when shopping for an ice cream maker is the quality of the ice cream that it produces.

The Whynter ICM 200LS is a great machine for the quality of the ice cream, but it might not produce the most consistent results. The ice cream can be a bit icy, and the flavor might not be as strong as you’d like.

On the other hand, the Breville Smart Scoop is a wonderful machine that does a great job when it comes to making delicious and consistent ice cream. This machine makes up to 1 and ½ quarts of ice cream or sorbet in as little as 20 minutes.

Learn more about the Breville Smart Scoop in our detailed review here. 

Whynter vs Breville Ice Cream Maker Performance Comparison

Both ice cream makers offer great performance. However, their design is different, meaning they might not produce the best results in terms of consistency or taste.

The Whynter ICM 200LS is a classic ice cream maker made out of plastic and has a big crank on top. This machine is simple to use, but it can be a bit messy since the ice cream tends to stick on the sides.

On the other hand, Breville Smart Scoop comes with a sleek design made out of brushed stainless steel. This machine has a number of features, such as a timer and auto-shut-off, that make it easier to use. The Breville Smart Scoop can keep the ice cream consistent because it has a built-in compressor.

Whynter Ice Cream Maker Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • The machine is simple and comes with an on/off switch.
  • It’s a great machine for making delicious ice cream.
  • The ice cream maker doesn’t produce a lot of noise
  • It comes at an affordable price tag
  • It has a high-quality stainless steel housing
  • It is easy to clean

Cons:

  • The ice cream can be a bit icy, and the flavor might not be as strong as you’d like.

Breville Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • It’s a high-quality ice cream maker that is made with stainless steel.
  • The auto shut-off feature makes it easier to use.
  • This machine is great at making creamy and delicious ice cream.
  • It has a stylish and sleek design that would look great in your kitchen.
  • The machine is easy to clean and doesn’t produce any noise when in use.

Cons:

  • The price might be too high for budget-conscious consumers, but it’s worth it because of the number of features and the performance.

Whynter ICM 200LS vs Breville Smart Scoop Value: Which Machine Should You Get?

Whynter and the Breville Smart Scoop are both great ice cream makers that can produce delicious and creamy ice cream. However, these machines have some differences that might influence your decision on which one you should get.

For those who want an affordable yet high-quality ice cream maker, Whynter ICM 200LS is a great option. This machine has stainless steel housing and doesn’t produce a lot of noise when in use. It’s simple to use and comes with an on/off switch.

On the other hand, for those who want a high-quality ice cream maker that is easy to use and comes with a sleek design, the Breville Smart Scoop is a wonderful machine to get. This ice cream maker comes with an auto shut-off feature and has a stylish design that would look great in any kitchen. It also makes amazing and consistent ice cream, and it’s easy to clean.

Compare the Breville Smart Scoop vs Cuisinart ICE 100 – we have a go-to guide to answer all your questions! 

What to Consider When Buying an Ice Cream Maker

When it comes to making your ice cream at home, there are a few things you need to consider before making your purchase. Both Whynter and Breville smart scoop come with some of these great factors, and all you need to do is make your comparison. Let’s take a look!

The Capacity

The capacity of the machine you choose depends on how much ice cream you want to make at one time. If you are looking for a machine that can make a lot of ice cream, then the Whynter ICM 200LS is a good option because it can make up to 2 quarts of ice cream.

The Breville Smart Scoop, on the other hand, only makes 1 and ½ quarts of ice cream, but it comes with a sleek design and a number of features that make it easier to use.

The capacity also goes hand in hand with the physical size of your ice cream maker. You have to consider the space in your kitchen when choosing an ice cream maker.

The Type of Ice Cream Maker

There are two types of ice cream makers- the batch freezer and the continuous freezer. A batch freezer is a machine that you have to put the ingredients in and let it churn for a set amount of time. After, you have to take it out and put it in the freezer to let it set. A continuous freezer is a machine that you can keep adding ingredients too, and the ice cream will churn until it’s done.

The Design

When it comes to the design of the machine, you might prefer one over the other. The Whynter ICM 200LS is made out of plastic and has a big crank on top. Some people might not like the design because of its bulky appearance. The Breville Smart Scoop, on the other hand, is made with stainless steel and has a sleek and stylish design. It’s also easy to clean because all the parts are removable.

The Price

The machine’s price is another thing you have to consider when making your decision. The Whynter ICM 200LS is much more affordable than the Breville Smart Scoop. However, the Breville Smart Scoop comes with many features that make it easier to use and produce high-quality ice cream.

Ease of Use

You need a machine that will give you an easy time operating. It should even be friendly ice cream maker for the kids to use since they might need some treats while you’re busy or away. Both machines are easy to use, but the Breville Smart Scoop has a few more features that make it easier to operate. The auto shut-off feature is very helpful and ensures that your ice cream doesn’t over-churn. You can check out the Whynter user manual for extra details. 

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a compressor ice cream maker worth it?

A compressor ice cream maker is a machine that doesn’t require you to put your ingredients in a freezer first like some of the other machines. It has a built-in compressor that helps it stay cold and churn your ice cream. This type of machine is definitely worth the investment because it will save you time and produce high-quality ice cream.

What’s the difference between ice cream and gelato?

Ice cream is usually sweet and has a smooth texture. It’s made with milk, heavy cream, sugar, and other ingredients. Gelato is an Italian ice cream that is denser than most ice creams because it uses less air during the churning process.

Which ice cream maker makes the creamiest ice cream?

Among the two ice cream makers compared in this review, the Breville Smart Scoop produces the creamiest ice cream. It has a built-in compressor that makes it churn at a low temperature and adds air to the mixture while it churns, resulting in high-quality ice cream.

Our Verdict – Whynter ICM 200LS vs Breville Smart Scoop

The Whynter ICM 200LS and the Breville Smart Scoop are good options among ice cream makers. The choice of which one to buy depends on your preferences. If you want an affordable machine that’s easy to use, then go for the Whynter ICM 200LS. On the other hand, if you’re looking for a machine that has a sleek design and produces high-quality ice cream, then the Breville Smart Scoop is the one for you.

But before making your purchase, be sure to consider the above factors to make the best decision for your needs. Also, go through what other customers say about Whynter ICM 200LS vs Breville Smart Scoop, as this can help you make the right decision.