ice cream maker guru

Whynter ICM 200LS vs Cuisinart ICE 100 Comparison

Choosing among two great ice cream makers, Whynter ICM 200LS vs Cuisinart ICE 100, can be an uphill task if you don’t know what to look for. While the ice cream maker machines may look the same and even perform almost the same, you still need to consider a few factors to make the right decision.

Whynter ICM 200LS vs Cuisinart ICE 100

The following is a head-to-head comparison of Whynter vs Cuisinart ice cream maker based on some important features, pros, cons, value, etc. Let’s see if this can help you make the right buying decision for an ice cream maker.

How Does the Whynter ICM 200LS Compare to the Cuisinart ICE 100?

Product
Whynter ICM 200LS
Cuisinart ICE 100
Whynter ICM-200LS Automatic Ice Cream Maker 2 Quart Capacity Stainless Steel, Built-in Compressor,...
Cuisinart ICE-100 1.5-Quart Ice Cream and Gelato Maker, Fully Automatic with a Commercial Quality...
Overall Score
5/5
5/5
Type
Compressor
Compressor
Capacity
2.1 quarts
1.5 quarts
Weight
24.25 lbs
27.2 lbs
Churn Time
25 minutes
30 minutes
Warranty
2 years
3 years
Bottom Line
The Whynter ICM 200LS churns out high-quality ice cream and comes with some great additional features
Cuisinart ICE 100 is a great family-size ice cream maker that doesn't require much pre-freezing
Product
Whynter ICM 200LS
Whynter ICM-200LS Automatic Ice Cream Maker 2 Quart Capacity Stainless Steel, Built-in Compressor,...
Overall Score
5/5
Type
Compressor
Capacity
2.1 quarts
Weight
24.25 lbs
Churn Time
25 minutes
Warranty
2 years
Bottom Line
The Whynter ICM 200LS churns out high-quality ice cream and comes with some great additional features
More Info
Product
Cuisinart ICE 100
Cuisinart ICE-100 1.5-Quart Ice Cream and Gelato Maker, Fully Automatic with a Commercial Quality...
Overall Score
5/5
Type
Compressor
Capacity
1.5 quarts
Weight
27.2 lbs
Churn Time
30 minutes
Warranty
3 years
Bottom Line
Cuisinart ICE 100 is a great family-size ice cream maker that doesn't require much pre-freezing
More Info

Whynter ICM 200LS vs Cuisinart ICE 100 Key Features

Capacity

When it comes to capacity, the Whynter ICM 200LS beats Cuisinart ICE 100 by almost double the quantity of ice cream. Whynter, an ice cream maker, can churn up to 2.1 quarts of ice cream, while the Cuisinart can only manage 1.5 quarts. So if you are looking for a machine that can churn more ice cream for the entire family or guests, go for the Whynter. However, if you’re looking for a family-size ice cream maker, the Cuisinart will do just fine.

Ice Cream Quality

Another factor worth looking for when choosing between these two incredible ice cream makers is the ice cream quality.  Both ice cream makers feature incredible Plastic mixing bowls that ensure the quality of the ice cream is consistent and smooth.

So if you’re looking for a machine that will churn out high-quality ice cream, both Whynter and Cuisinart ice cream makers can work well in your favor.

Appearance

When it comes to looks, both machines look incredible and will make excellent additions to your kitchen countertop. Cuisinart comes in a beautiful stainless steel and plastic finish. The combination of these two materials in the body of the ice cream maker is perfect. The top and the front part come in perfectly shiny stainless steel, while the bottom and sides are made of durable plastic.

The Whynter ice cream maker doesn’t lag behind either when it comes to appearance as it also features durable stainless steel construction.  The only downside to the Whynter is that it doesn’t have a plastic finish like Cuisinart. So if you’re looking for a machine with a more polished look, go for the Cuisinart.

For a deeper look into the Cuisinart ICE 100 – check out our detailed review. 

Ease of Use

Both machines are incredibly easy to use and don’t require any prior experience in making ice cream. However, there are a few differences you need to be aware of. For instance, the Whynter requires you to pre-freeze the mixing bowl 24 hours before use, while the Cuisinart doesn’t.

Additionally, the Whynter comes with an automatic shutoff feature that turns off the machine after a certain period. This is a great feature if you forget to shut it off manually. The Cuisinart doesn’t have the automatic shutoff feature, but it’s not a big problem as you can easily turn it off when done using it.

Noise Levels

The customers using both machines have no complaints about the noise levels. It seems both are very silent when freezing the ice cream, so you can use them without worrying about the noise disturbing the rest of the family.

However, there’s still a great difference when it comes to the decibels of the noise. The Cuisinart is a little bit louder than the Whynter ice cream maker. It produces up to 85db, while the Whynter only produces up to 72db. So if you’re looking for a more silent machine, the Whynter is better suited for you.

Dimensions and Weight

The dimensions of both machines are almost identical, with a few minor differences. In terms of height and length, both are the same. However, the Whynter is shorter and wider than the Cuisinart ice cream maker.

The dimensions and weight of both machines are very important, especially if you’ll be moving them around your home or kitchen frequently. If you’re looking for a machine that’s lightweight and compact, go for Whynter, as it only weighs 24 pounds. The Cuisinart machine is a bit heavier as it weighs up to 27 pounds.

Additional Features

For an additional cost, Whynter comes with a handy dandy ice cream scoop that makes adding ingredients and serving ice cream much easier. Additionally, the Whynter ice cream maker comes with a transparent lid that allows you to watch the ice cream being made.

The Cuisinart ice cream maker also has great additional features other than the stainless steel finish. It has a manual timer, keeps cool, pre-cool, harness setting knob, and music buttons. All these features are shown in an incredible LCD display screen.

The Price

The price of the ice cream maker is also a great differentiating factor to look for. Both Cuisinart and Whynter are not so different in price, but there are a few variations. The Whynter is a bit more expensive, but it’s worth the extra money as you’re getting additional features. But both the machines are pretty affordable and won’t break the bank.

Whynter Stainless Steel ICM-200LS Automatic Ice Cream Maker

Whynter ICM 200LS Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Churns up to 2.1 quarts of ice cream
  • It comes with an automatic shutoff feature
  • It has a handy dandy ice cream scoop
  • Churns quality ice cream that tastes exactly like professional made
  • This machine makes both soft and hard serve ice cream
  • A user-friendly machine that features auto functions

Cons:

  • Requires you to pre-freeze the mixing bowl for 24 hours before use
  • Some users complain that the machine fails to start after some times

Cuisinart ICE 100 Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • It comes in an attractive stainless steel finish with durable plastic parts to ensure the sturdiness of the machine
  • Features a transparent lid that allows you to watch the ice cream being made while it’s being churned up
  • Churns up to 1.5 quarts of ice cream
  • It is incredibly easy to use and doesn’t require any prior experience in making ice cream
  • It has a manual timer, keep cool, pre-cool, harness setting knob, and music buttons.
  • All these features are shown in an incredible LCD display screen

Cons:

  • The Cuisinart doesn’t have an automatic shutoff feature as the Whynter does

Whynter ICM 200LS vs Cuisinart ICE 100 Value for Money

So, which ice cream maker should you buy between the two?

If you’re looking for a machine that churns out high-quality ice cream and comes with some great additional features, the Whynter ICM 200LS is the perfect choice for you. However, if you’re looking for an affordable family-size ice cream maker that doesn’t require much pre-freezing, the Cuisinart ICE-21 is a better option.

Both ice cream makers offer great value for money, and you can never regret buying any of them. They both make quality ice cream and are perfect for those who want to make homemade ice cream.

Still trying to decide? Check out out other comparisons! Whynter vs Breville Smart Scoop Comparison and our Breville Smart Scoop vs Cuisinart ICE 100 

What to Look for When Buying an Ice Cream Maker

 

The Machine Type

Are you looking for a compressor ice cream maker or a freezer bowl machine?

Compressor machines are more expensive, but they come with a lot more features. They’re perfect for those who want to make ice cream frequently. Freezer bowl machines are less expensive and don’t require as much pre-freezing, but they can only make a limited amount of ice cream.

Ice Cream Maker Size

Ice cream makers come in different sizes. Decide how much ice cream you want to make at a time, and then find an ice cream maker that matches your needs.  Most ice cream makers have a capacity of between 1 and 2 quarts. In most cases, this capacity range is enough to make enough ice cream for your family or friends. If you want to make more, you might consider buying an additional freezer bowl.

The Ease of Use

Some ice cream makers are really easy to use, while others might require some prior experience in making ice cream before you can get it right. Decide how much time you’re willing to put into the machine and find one that matches your needs. It’s always advisable to choose an ice cream maker that you can use straight out of the box, like the Cuisinart ICE 100.

The Price

Ice cream makers vary in price, but most of them are affordable. Choose an ice cream maker that fits your budget without compromising on quality. Remember, you always get what you pay for. If you want quality and creamy ice cream, you might have to pay a little more.

The Extras

Some ice cream makers come with additional features such as a transparent lid, an automatic shutoff feature, a handy dandy ice cream scoop, etc. Depending on your needs, these features might not be necessary, but they are definitely an added bonus.

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s the best way to use a Whynter ICM 200LS?

The best way to use a Whynter ice cream maker is by pre-freezing the mixing bowl that comes with it for 24 hours. If you skip this step, the machine might not work perfectly.

What is the difference between the Cuisinart ICE 100 and the Whynter ICM 200LS?

The main difference between these two machines is that the Whynter comes with an automatic shutoff feature while the Cuisinart ice cream maker doesn’t. The Whynter also comes with a handy dandy ice cream scoop, while the Cuisinart doesn’t. Additionally, the Whynter has a transparent lid that allows you to watch the ice cream being made while it’s being churned up.

What is the difference between a hard and a soft-serve ice cream machine?

A hard serve ice cream machine is one that churns up ice cream that is firm and has a melt-in-your-mouth texture. This type of ice cream is perfect for those looking to build and construct their own ice cream treats such as sundaes and cakes. 

On the other hand, a soft-serve machine churns out light, airy, creamy ice cream that can be served right out of the machine and doesn’t require much freezing after. Soft serve ice cream is better for those looking to make shakes and smoothies as it’s lighter than hard-serve ice creams.

Is Cuisinart ICE 100 a compressor ice cream maker?

No, the Cuisinart ICE 100 is not a compressor ice cream maker. It doesn’t require freezing or pre-freezing before you use it to make ice cream. Instead, it uses the freezer method that involves putting in some ice and salt with your mix to freeze up the mixture.

Is Whynter ICM 200LS a compressor ice cream maker?

Yes, the Whynter ICM 200LS is a compressor ice cream maker that requires you to pre-freeze the mixing bowl for 24 hours before using it. Without pre-freezing, the machine might not work perfectly.

Our Verdict

Now that you know some features that differentiate these two ice cream makers, you must be ready to make your choice. Just to give you a recap, the Cuisinart ICE 100 is a solid all-around ice cream maker that’s simple to use and affordable. It works fast, churns up quality creamy homemade ice cream with ease, and can be stored away easily after each use.

The Whynter ICM 200LS is great for those looking for versatility as you can make different types of desserts in it. If you’re okay with pre-freezing the mixing bowl, the Whynter is an awesome machine that churns up quality homemade ice cream without any issues.

Whichever machine you choose will depend on your specific needs and preferences, but Cuisinart ICE 100 and Whynter ICM 200LS are solid choices that won’t disappoint. With this Whynter ICM 200LS vs Cuisinart ICE 100 comparison, you must already know exactly the machine to go for.

Happy Ice Cream Making!